2021: The Unstable Realities of Christopher Priest
Shortlisted — British Fantasy Award for Non-Fiction
shortlisted — BSFA non-fiction award
2018: Iain M. Banks
winner -- BSFA Non-Fiction Award
shortlisted -- hugo award, best related work
Finalist -- Locus Award, non-Fiction
2015: Call And Response
SHORTLISTED -- BSFA Non-Fiction Award
2013: "The Widening Gyre", Los Angeles Review of Books, 3 September 2012
shortlisted -- bsfa non-fiction award
2009: What it is we do when we read science fiction
shortlisted -- Hugo Award, Best Related Book
shortlisted -- BSFA Non-Fiction Award
finalist -- Locus Award, Non-Fiction/Art Book
shortlisted -- British Fantasy Award, Non-Fiction
2007: The Arthur C. Clarke Award: A Critical Anthology edited by Paul Kincaid with Andrew M. Butler
Recommended Reading -- BSFA Non-Fiction Award
2006:
Winner -- Thomas D. Clareson Award for Distinguished Service
2006: "Blank Pages: Islands and Identity in the Fiction of Christopher Priest", Christopher Priest: The Interaction edited by Andrew M. Butler
recommended reading -- BSFA Non-Fiction Award
1999:
winner -- GUFF (Get Up-and-over Fan Fund)
1998: "Last Day of the Carnival: 36 Exposures", Back Brain Recluse, number 23, 1997
shortlisted -- BSFA Short Fiction Award
1996: Jointly with Maureen Kincaid Speller